Top Court Cases of 2024

It's Friday! Today we cover the top court cases of 2024 plus how you can discuss them in applications and interviews.

Are you new here? Get free emails to your inbox.

We're covering 8 cases including:

• 🏢 Vatican's Property Drama
• 💉 Vaccine Patent Showdown
• ⚽ Premier League v Man City
• 💸 The Dividend Fraud

Vatican Drama

In Short: The Holy See takes on Athena Capital and financier Raffaele Mincione in a London courtroom drama over a controversial €350m property deal, involving Harrods' former furniture depot and allegations of fraud and corruption.

What’s this about?
The Holy See's claim against Athena Capital, WRM Capital, and Raffaele Mincione is all about a property transaction turned sour. The Vatican's administrative body, the Secretariat of State, bought Harrods' old furniture warehouse from Mincione for €350m with grand plans to transform it into luxury flats.

However, the deal went south, and the property was offloaded at a hefty loss, sparking a scandal with all the trimmings with alleged corruption, and even a Vatican-led criminal trial. Mincione, acquitted on fraud but caught for embezzlement and laundering, is fighting to clear his name in London's Commercial Court.

Taking place: 24 June 2024, for 14 days.

Key Points to Discuss:

1. Jurisdictional Jousting: This case marks the first time the Vatican has graced an English courtroom, a fact that adds a layer of international intrigue and complexity. The UK courts were deemed to have jurisdiction because the case involved a property transaction that took place in London, specifically the sale of a luxury property by Italian financier Raffaele Mincione to the Vatican.
2. Property Deal Pitfalls: At the heart of this dispute is a property transaction gone wrong. The case sheds light on the risks and complications in high-stakes real estate deals, especially when they involve international players and potential corruption. It's a cautionary tale for both investors and lawyers, emphasising due diligence and the unpredictability of property investments.
3. Legal and Moral Reputation: Beyond the financial and legal ramifications, this case touches on the delicate balance between legal judgments and moral reputation. For Mincione, the London case could be his last stand to salvage his reputation, especially if his Vatican appeal falls flat. On the flip side, the Vatican is keen to uphold its judicial decisions and avoid contradictory rulings from a foreign court.

Which law firms are advising on this?